Claire Heddles of the Miami Herald: "Palm Beach County commissioners will take their first public vote Tuesday on the renaming of Palm Beach International Airport after Donald Trump, now that county officials have reached a tentative trademark deal with the president’s companies following weeks of negotiations. The controversial deal is unusual: other airports named after presidents don’t have trademarks owned by private companies. Trump’s companies and Palm Beach County administrators have argued the trademark agreement is necessary to protect the county from lawsuits, not for private profit.A copy of the agreement signed by Trump Sunday and reviewed by the Miami Herald, however, shows it could leave openings for Trump’s businesses and family members to benefit from the taxpayer-funded airport name change. " Read on. Thanks to RAS for what looks to be a gift link. ~~~
~~~ Marie: This is outrageous. The voters of Palm Beach County should get rid of these commissioners right now. Do a recall, for Pete's sake. The county has voted for the Democratic presidential candidate in every election since at least 2008. That means they voted against Trump three times. And they're naming a public airport after Trump and allowing him to maneuver a way to make money off of it?? Just horrible. What is the matter with these people? The only way they could do worse would be to name the airport for some other infamous Palm Beach resident, like, you know, Epstein International.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Here's the New York Times' liveblog of developments in the Iran war. From the pinned item at 5:00 am ET: “The Middle East truce faltered on Monday, as the United Arab Emirates said it had been attacked by Iran, while the U.S. military said that it had destroyed six Iranian military boats and that Iran had fired on American ships in the Strait of Hormuz. The Emirati authorities blamed Iran for a drone attack that caused a fire in the Fujairah Oil Industry Zone, the largest oil storage area in the Emirates, in the first such assault since a cease-fire was reached in early April. In neighboring Oman, two people were injured by an attack in Bukha, near Emirati territory, according to an Omani state news agency, which did not identify the culprit. Adm. Brad Cooper, the head of the military’s Central Command, said that U.S. warships shot down cruise missiles and drones that Iran fired at the ships and commercial vessels the Navy was guiding through the Strait of Hormuz. U.S. Central Command said that Army helicopters destroyed six Iranian military speedboats that threatened the ships in the strait.... [Donald] Trump said Iran had 'taken some shots at unrelated Nations,' including a South Korea cargo ship, in connection with an initiative he announced on Sunday to help guide stranded ships out of the strait. Mr. Trump said that aside from the South Korean ship, there had been 'no damage going through the Strait.'”
James LaPorta of CBS News: "Two U.S. Navy destroyers transited the Strait of Hormuz and entered the Persian Gulf after navigating an Iranian barrage, according to defense officials who spoke to CBS News under condition of anonymity to discuss national security matters. The USS Truxtun and USS Mason, supported by Apache helicopters and other aircraft, faced a series of coordinated threats during the passage, the defense officials said. Iran launched small boats, missiles and drones against them in what officials described as a sustained barrage. Despite the intensity of the attacks, neither U.S. vessel was struck. Military officials said that defensive measures, bolstered by air support, successfully intercepted or deterred each incoming threat. They added that no projectiles that were launched reached the ships."
Adam Schreck & Sam Metz of the AP: “The United Arab Emirates said Monday it came under attack by Iran for the first time since a fragile ceasefire took hold in early April. The attacks appeared to be in response to ... Donald Trump’s latest efforts to reopen the Strait of Hormuz.... The UAE Defense Ministry said Iran had launched four cruise missiles, with three shot down and one falling into the sea. Authorities in the eastern emirate of Fujairah said an Iranian drone sparked a fire at a key oil facility, wounding three Indian nationals. The British military reported two cargo vessels ablaze off the UAE. The attacks came after the U.S. military said two American-flagged merchant ships had successfully transited the Strait of Hormuz after it launched a new initiative to restore traffic Monday.” (Also linked yesterday.)
Heather Cox Richardson: “Trump told Trey Yingst of the Fox News Channel today that his military blockade of Iranian ports is the 'greatest military maneuver in history.' He also said that if the Iranians target U.S. ships, they will be 'blown off the face of the earth.'” So Trump is the greatest military genius in history AND he's vowing to commit a massive war crime if he doesn't get his way. Surely any reputable psychiatrist who assessed Trump would say he is stark, staring mad, though possibly using more appropriate professional terminology.
It Is a War Waged by an Idiot, Full of Sound and Fury, Accomplishing Nothing. Gram Slattery, et al., of Reuters, published by the Japan Times: "U.S. intelligence assessments indicate that the time Iran would need to build a nuclear weapon has not changed since last summer, when analysts estimated that a U.S.-Israeli attack had pushed back the timeline to up to a year, according to three sources familiar with the matter. The assessments of Tehran’s nuclear program remain broadly unchanged even after two months of a war that ... Donald Trump launched in part to stop the Islamic Republic from developing a nuclear bomb.”
Paul Krugman points out that Trump's war in Iran has highlighted and exacerbated a second war Trump is losing: “... the closure of the Strait of Hormuz marks an inflection point: the global green energy curve, which was already on a rapidly rising trajectory, has suddenly become even steeper.... This acceleration isn’t just a consequence of soaring fossil fuel prices. It is also the result of the worldwide realization that, with the end of Pax Americana, depending on imported hydrocarbons is a risk not worth taking. The United States cannot be relied on to keep sea lanes open when cheap drones can take out an oil tanker or a major pipeline. Even relying on oil and gas from America itself is dangerous, since one never knows when an erratic U.S. government – now under the control of a twice-elected malignant narcissist — will try to use energy as a tool of coercion.... Trump and the fossil-fuel cabal may be able to extract a few billion dollars in profits by keeping America stuck in a dirty-energy past. But in so doing they will also ensure that the United States is left behind, and that the future belongs to China.”
Marie: When Trump announced in a recent middle-of-the-night tweetorama that he was withdrawing 5,000 troops from Germany (to the Pentagon's surprise), I blamed it on German Chancellor Fred Mertz for hurting Trump's feelings. Rachel Maddow has another idea, and I'll buy that:
Anatoly Kurmanaev of the New York Times: “U.S. and Venezuelan officials have promised a new era of accountability for Venezuela’s lucrative oil industry after the downfall of President Nicolás Maduro.... [Donald] Trump said the United States would control Venezuelan oil sales. Venezuela would submit monthly budgets to the White House, the Trump administration said, and the United States said it hired auditors to check receipts. Venezuela’s new leader and Mr. Trump’s ally, Delcy Rodríguez, said the public could trace every oil dollar on a new website. None of these initiatives, however, have thus far shed light on where Venezuela’s oil money has been going....”
John Yoon of the New York Times: “The U.S. military said on Monday that it had struck another boat in the Caribbean Sea, killing two men as part of a campaign against people the Trump administration accuses of smuggling drugs by sea. The strike was ordered by Gen. Francis L. Donovan, the head of the U.S. Southern Command, which oversees operations in Latin America, Central America and the Caribbean, the command said in a statement. The two deaths raised the overall toll to at least 187 in the U.S. campaign against boats in the Caribbean and the eastern Pacific. There have been more than 50 strikes since the campaign began in September.”
Erica Green & Zolan Kanno-Youngs of the New York Times: Donald “Trump on Monday sought to portray his policy wins for small businesses as evidence that he was succeeding in building up the economy.... The White House described the Small Business Week event as highlighting 'the extraordinary revival of Main Street under his America First agenda.' But looming over it all was a war abroad that Mr. Trump had begun, and whose economic impact is compounding cost-of-living concerns among Americans, many of whom increasingly say their economic reality has worsened under his tenure. Mr. Trump’s comments on Monday created a sharp contrast with the economic reality outside Washington, as rising energy prices hammer families and businesses alike.... During the event on Monday, [Mr. Trump] sought to downplay the rising cost of energy, saying that it had been projected to rise much more, and that he saw it 'going down very substantially' soon....
“During the more than one-hour speech on Monday, Mr. Trump veered off into other topics, including criticizing former President Joseph R. Biden Jr., boasting about passing cognitive tests and complaining about polls and media coverage. He also offered a lengthy account of how he had decided to renovate the reflecting pool at the National Mall.” MB: He also fell asleep standing up.
Trump's Toxic Waste Dump # 1. Maxine Joselow of the New York Times: “Soil at a public golf course in Washington where the Trump administration dumped debris from the demolition of the White House East Wing has tested positive for lead, chromium and other toxic metals, according to data released by the National Park Service. The data, which the Park Service published on its website last week, showed relatively low levels of these contaminants in the soil at East Potomac Golf Links. Yet ... some of the samples exceeded what California regulators, who have taken a more aggressive approach than has the federal government, consider safe levels of lead in industrial settings....
“The dump raised questions about the decision by the Trump administration to bypass environmental laws when it dropped truckloads of mud, rebar, plaster and other debris in the middle of the popular public course near the Jefferson Memorial. The president is planning a sweeping overhaul of the 105-year-old golf course, where generations have played in view of monuments and memorials at bargain rates that currently run $42 for 18 holes on weekdays. Mr. Trump wants to transform it into a championship course, which would likely spell the end to an existing mini-golf course as well as a surrounding roadway that is popular with cyclists and runners.” Update: the link has been changed to one that appears to be a gift link. ~~~
~~~ Joshua Chapin of ABC 7 News (Washington, D.C.): "East Potomac Golf Links remains open for now. That was in question over the weekend as federal officials had planned to close the place and the existing parkland for a massive overhaul. A district court judge on Monday morning ruled that the government must provide reasonable notice if it plans to close the golf course or cut down as few as 10 trees. Over the weekend, lawyers for the D.C. Preservation League filed a motion to halt work at the course, and that seems to have worked."
Oh, Give Me a Home Where the Buffalo Roam. Jack Healy of the New York Times: “... the Trump administration wants to evict ... hundreds of ... bison from ... [a Montana] range, and replace them with cattle. The resulting clash on the prairie has pitted ranchers and Republican leaders against a furry, snorting symbol of the American West.... The conflict centers on 900 bison owned by the group, which was allowed by multiple administrations, including ... [Donald] Trump’s first, to graze on federal lands, much to the consternation of politically conservative ranchers who wanted the land for cattle. This winter, the U.S. Bureau of Land Management reversed course and canceled the bison grazing permits. Citing the Taylor Grazing Act of 1934, the agency said the federal grasslands where the animals grazed should go to livestock being raised for food, not bison largely enjoying their right to roam. The agency deemed the bison to be wildlife, not production livestock. Conservation groups condemned the decision, as did Native American tribes, who say the anti-bison effort threatens their own herds as they try to revive bison populations that were hunted to near extinction by 19th-century settlers.”
Ashleigh Fields of the Hill: “A new poll found that most Americans say they believe ... [Donald] Trump is mentally and physically unfit to serve as commander in chief. The Washington Post-ABC News-Ipsos poll found that 59 percent of U.S. respondents said that Trump does not have the mental sharpness it takes to lead the country.... Comparatively, 55 percent of U.S. adults said Trump is not in good enough physical health to serve as president.... More than half of respondents, 54 percent, said they do not believe the president is a strong leader. Sixty-seven percent of survey participants also said they don’t think Trump carefully considers important decisions.” MB: I only occasionally link polls, and I skipped this one when the WashPo published the results yesterday. But I liked Fields' lede, so I went with it.
Marie: I often write that Everything Trump Does Is Wrong. Rachel Maddow puts it another way: "This administration is bad at everything they set their mind to ... except one thing":
Tom Wellborn well may have written the best description of Donald Trump -- whom he does not name -- that I've ever read -- and I've read a lot of excellent ones, including on the pages of Reality Chex. Thanks to RAS for this dazzling link. (Also linked yesterday.)
Glenn Thrush, et al., of the New York Times: “The Secret Service shot and wounded an armed man on Monday afternoon just south of the White House in a burst of gunfire that also grazed a young bystander in an area packed with pedestrians, officials said. There was no indication that the man, who was taken to a hospital with multiple gunshot wounds, was targeting anyone in the executive complex, Chris McDonald, a congressional affairs official with the Secret Service, wrote in an email to Congress after the episode. 'President Trump was not in any danger, and there is currently no known nexus between the incident and the White House,' Mr. McDonald wrote. A motorcade with Vice President JD Vance had passed through the area — a heavily trafficked route for official vehicles, as well as people visiting the nearby Washington Monument — shortly before the confrontation took place, officials told reporters.” ~~~
~~~ Sophia Solano, et al., of the Washington Post: “The White House was briefly locked down Monday afternoon after a U.S. Secret Service officer exchanged gunfire with an armed individual nearby, the agency said.” An NBC News story is here.
Dan Mangan of CNBC: "A U.S. Secret Service officer was arrested Monday in Miami on a charge of indecent exposure while off-duty, authorities said. The officer, John Spillman, had worked hours earlier on exterior security screening for ... Donald Trump’s appearance Sunday at the PGA Tour’s Cadillac Championship, which was being held at the Trump National Doral. Spillman was held at the Miami-Dade County Jail in lieu of a $1,000 bond on Monday, online jail records showed. The 33-year-old has been placed on administrative leave from the Secret Service, the agency said.... Police said they responded to the [Double Tree Inn] in response to a call about a man who was naked on the sixth floor. When police arrived, they found Spillman 'masturbating at the end of the hallway,' the arrest report said.” Oh, read on.
Nick Corasaniti, et al., of the New York Times: “The Justice Department has demanded the identities of every worker who staffed the 2020 election in Fulton County, Ga., according to court records, escalating an ongoing federal investigation of the 2020 vote in Georgia’s most populous county that relies on false and debunked claims.The demand targets employees of Fulton County elections as well as volunteer poll workers, who likely numbered in the thousands during the 2020 election, according to court records. The demand, which came via a federal grand jury subpoena, appears to be the latest effort by ... [Donald] Trump and his administration to use the investigative power of the federal government to pursue false claims that the 2020 election was stolen. With midterm voting underway in many states, including Georgia, the effort risks further undermining public confidence and sowing chaos among voters. It is not known what the Justice Department intends to do with the names of election workers.” MB: Well, for one thing, harass workers who earn a few dollars an hour for a few days' work each year to assuage the ego of a doddering old megalomaniac. Update: the link has been changed to one that looks like a gift link.
Salvador Rizzo & Andrew Ackerman of the Washington Post: “The Justice Department no longer plans to appeal a court ruling that quashed two subpoenas directed at the Federal Reserve and its chairman, the latest sign of surrender from U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro in the politically thorny probe of the independent central bank, according to a legal filing Monday.... When Pirro closed the probe on April 24, she said her office still intended to appeal a ruling by Chief U.S. District Judge James E. Boasberg of D.C., who had effectively halted the investigation by quashing two grand-jury subpoenas that had been issued to the Fed and [Fed chair Jerome] Powell.... Instead, prosecutors in the U.S. attorney’s office filed court papers [Monday] asking Boasberg to throw out his prior rulings in the case.” MB: Because they want to be able to bring baseless nuisance cases whenever Trump demands it.
Kyle Cheney & Josh Gerstein of Politico: “A federal judge said Monday that the Trump administration had put her security at risk by posting a 'patently false' allegation that she knowingly released an ICE detainee with an international warrant for murder. Justice Department attorney Kevin Bolan profusely apologized to Rhode Island-based U.S. District Judge Melissa DuBose for the press release posted last week by the Department of Homeland Security, which Bolan acknowledged 'simply was not true.' Bolan said that he didn’t tell the judge about the foreign arrest warrant because Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials instructed him not to. The officials, Bolan said, were concerned that law enforcement in the Dominican Republic, where the warrant was issued, had not signed off on sharing that information. But DuBose noted that the Trump administration itself had publicly disclosed the existence of the warrant in a press release earlier last month. She also noted that the April 30 release slamming her — 'Activist Biden Judge Releases Violent Criminal Illegal Alien Wanted for Murder' — remained online Monday.... DuBose said at the hearing Monday that she is considering whether to hold officials from DHS or DOJ in contempt of court for their handling of the situation.”
The New DHS Secretary Is Just Like the Other One. Dave Jamieson & Matt Shuham of the Huffington Post: “The Department of Homeland Security is closing an office responsible for investigating misconduct and abuse in the immigration detention system, according to an internal email to DHS employees obtained by HuffPost. The Office of the Immigration Detention Ombudsman is in the process of removing all its public signage and ending its inspections, according to the email. The office’s public-facing website, which advised the families and attorneys of detainees on how to file complaints, was down as of Monday afternoon. Even basic informational webpages explaining the office’s responsibilities appeared to have been taken offline. The email attributed the closure to a lack of funding in the Homeland Security appropriations bill that ended the recent shutdown, though the text of that bill does not require the closure of the ombudsman’s office.”
Perry Stein & Aaron Schaffer of the Washington Post: “The Justice Department will remain blocked from examining electronic devices seized from a Washington Post reporter, a federal judge in Virginia ruled Monday. The ruling by U.S. District Judge Anthony J. Trenga marks the second time a court in the Eastern District of Virginia has rejected efforts by the Justice Department to sift through a phone, computers and other devices belonging to Post reporter Hannah Natanson. The FBI seized her belongings in January during an investigation of a government contractor accused of leaking classified material.”
The House of Representatives Is a Festering Cesspool of Abusive Men. Hailey Fuchs of Politico: “The federal government paid out more than $338,000 to settle allegations of sexual harassment on behalf of House members or their offices since 2004 — far more than had been previously known — according to Rep. Nancy Mace and a person granted anonymity.... The panel subpoenaed the information detailing the government payouts after a March committee vote, seeking a full accounting of secret payouts made before the settlements were ended in 2018. Some of the payments have been previously reported, but not all. Mace (R-S.C.) released a list of offices that had been implicated in the settlements, including former Reps. Eric Massa (D-N.Y.), John Conyers (D-Mich.), Blake Farenthold (R-Texas) and Patrick Meehan (R-Pa.) — all of whom have been previously publicly implicated in misconduct. Mace also listed a settlement of $8,000 for the office of the late Rep. Carolyn McCarthy (D-N.Y.) as well as a $15,000 payout associated with former Rep. Rodney Alexander (R-La.). Alexander, who left Congress in 2013, said in a brief interview Monday the complaint concerned a former staffer, whom Alexander fired after learning of the accusation. A message to a former McCarthy aide ... was not immediately returned.” ~~~
~~~ MB: So we don't know if McCarthy was the alleged abuser or if the person was a staffer.
~~~ Kate Santaliz of Axios: "Rep. Chuck Edwards [R-N.C.] told a young female staffer that she had 'written a complex chapter in my heart' shortly before she was set to leave his office, according to a handwritten letter he sent her that was reviewed by Axios.... Edwards is now the subject of a House Ethics Committee probe, Axios first reported. That probe was prompted in part by Edwards' conduct toward two female staffers.... Three sources told Axios they witnessed conduct by Edwards toward two female staffers in their 20s that they described as inappropriate. The sources said Edwards' behavior crossed professional boundaries and created an uncomfortable work environment."
Marie: I can't believe it. Sam the Inquisitor defied my expectations: ~~~
~~~ Ann Marimow of the New York Times: “The Supreme Court on Monday restored nationwide access to a widely used abortion medication in a temporary order that will, for now, allow women to once again obtain the pill mifepristone by mail. In a brief order, Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. paused a lower-court ruling from Friday that had prevented abortion providers from prescribing the pills by telemedicine and shipping them to patients, causing confusion for providers and patients. The one-sentence order imposes a pause until at least May 11. He requested that the parties file briefs by Thursday, and then the full court will determine how to proceed.” The AP's report is here. (Also linked yesterday.)
Speedy Jim Crow. Abbie VanSickle & Emily Cochrane of the New York Times: “The Supreme Court on Monday evening agreed to immediately transmit to the lower courts its opinion striking down Louisiana’s congressional map, rather than wait 32 days, as would have been routine. Last week’s landmark opinion from the court, which weakened the Voting Rights Act by concluding that one of Louisiana’s majority-Black congressional districts was an unconstitutional racial gerrymander, has set off a chaotic scramble in the state.... It was not immediately clear what effect Monday’s decision to send the case back to the lower courts without delay would have on the effort to speedily redistrict. Those moves have been challenged in court.” ~~~
~~~ Sam Levine of the Guardian: “The US supreme court went out of its way on Monday to help Louisiana Republicans redraw their congressional maps before this year’s midterm elections by allowing a recent ruling that gutted a key part of the Voting Rights Act to take effect ahead of schedule.” MB: Don't tell he this cartoon is too much. These “justices” look better in their original white. Thanks to RAS for the link:
![]() |
| Cartoon by Chris Britt. |
The New York Times lists the Pulitzer Prize winners & their works which won the prizes.
~~~~~~~~~~
Florida Congressional Map. Gary Fineout of Politico: “Gov. Ron DeSantis on Monday signed into law a new congressional map that could help Republicans pick up four more seats in the House — a move that swiftly drew a lawsuit.... The new map was approved just days ago by the GOP-controlled Legislature and was put into place one week after the governor’s office delivered it to state legislators. Democrats have repeatedly called the map 'illegal' and a power grab designed to help Republicans keep hold of Congress in the upcoming midterm elections.The civil rights group Equal Ground Education Fund — along with a group of 19 Florida voters living in congressional districts across the state — asked a state judge to block the new map and reinstate the one that had been approved by the Legislature back in 2022. The lawsuit contends that the governor and Legislature violated voter-approved anti-gerrymandering standards. Those standards maintain that districts cannot be redrawn for partisan or to hurt or help incumbents.”

9 comments:
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/04/science/rfk-antidepressants-ssris-hhs-maha.html
The single greatest most effective and safest treatment for.America's depression would be this administration's mass resignation. Until then, we have the pills.
The Price of Vanity
"Last week’s round of self-glorification is nothing new. Trump has already bullied politicians or board members into renaming the Palm Beach airport and the Kennedy Center after him. He forced the National Park Service to add his face alongside George Washington’s on the annual park pass. A $60 million UFC event will celebrate his birthday on the White House lawn this June. Oh, and when asked what the massive, 250-foot arch he wants erected shall commemorate, Trump answered with his favorite word: 'me.'
So you’ll forgive Trump’s critics for concluding that his megalomaniacal second term ambitions have nothing to do with solving immigration, boosting the economy, or securing global peace. He’s too busy plastering his name, image, and tackky gold leafing on anything and everything he can.
Welcome to the Vanity Presidency, folks."
Yeah, but we've been in a Vanity Presidency for some time now. And it's costing us a shit ton, and not just money (although we've been lining his fat, bulging pockets for years now, and those of all his idiot spawn.
"As president, Trump’s need to trash-talk and own the room by making bold, headline-grabbing decisions wreaks damage on a far larger scale.
Shredding America’s hard-won reputation as a good-faith ally by mocking NATO has forced European governments to withhold vital intelligence, thereby degrading US national security. Taunting Canada compelled north-of-the-border businesses to remove American products from their shelves and convinced Canadian tourists to spend their coveted travel dollars elsewhere. Empowering Elon Musk’s DOGE goons to dismantle USAID programs in service to Trump’s insatiable need for splashy press conferences has (so far) killed an estimated 600,000 people — two-thirds of them children — in some of the poorest corners of the planet. Glibly responding to the covid pandemic by promising it would 'just go away' and giving credence to anti-vaxxer remedies like hydroxychloroquine caused additional sicknesses, hospitalizations, and deaths.
We could go on, but you get the point: Trump’s vanity is a political, economic, and humanitarian cancer."
Then there's Iran...and a broken economy, and a demented, waddling fool who is more interested in golf courses and ballrooms than doing anything of actual worth. 2028 can't get here soon enough.
The list of Pulitzer Prize winners and their works is testament to just how little we would know about what's going on in the bowels of "the most transparent administration in history" were it not for the press.
Pretty much--nothing.
May explain why I remain a print news junkie.
ICE Cruelty
"ICE has not paid for detainee medical care for 7 months
The termination of payments to providers has coincided with a massive spike in detainee deaths and medical crises."
McSweeneys
"Oil Prices Are Sky High, but At Least We’re Not Driving Energy Efficient Cars"
Medieval Emotional Support Animal
CNN
Don't support your coworker.
"VA conducted internal investigations into employees who attended vigil for Alex Pretti"
Trump To Control Merch At Florida Airport
"Palm Beach and a Trump company reached a tentative trademark deal to rename PBI
-Airport stores can only buy branded merchandise from Trump org approved retailers
-Gives Trump veto power over any biographical info in airport marketing materials"
Don't worry the state is laser focused on...making sure Black people have no voice in politics or the running of the government.
"The process of relocating people from New Orleans should start immediately, as the city has reached a “point of no return” that will see it surrounded by the ocean within decades due to the climate crisis, a stark new study has concluded.
Ongoing sea-level rise and the rampant erosion of wetlands in southern Louisiana will swallow up the New Orleans area within a few generations, with the new paper estimating the city “may well be surrounded by the Gulf of Mexico before the end of this century”."
Post a Comment